Direct Plan or Regular Plan: Which One Is Better?
Rise in financial awareness and easy access to market has encouraged many individual investors to make their own investment decisions. Also, growth of online investment platforms and technological advancements has allowed investors to purchase, sell and get other mutual fund services with no need of human intervention. However, Do-it-Yourself or DIY investors were still propelled to pay the distributor for the services they did not require. Considering the interest of such investors, direct plan was launched on 1st January, 2013 for all new and existing mutual fund schemes.
Get Your Free Credit Report with Monthly Updates Check Now
Difference between direct plans and regular plans
As the name suggests, in direct plans, investors can buy the fund directly from the AMCs or online platforms bypassing financial intermediaries. Those being purchased and sold via intermediaries are categorized as regular plans. Both plans share similarities in terms of investment style, investment objectives, fund management, asset allocation strategy, portfolio composition and benchmark indices. Like regular plans, investors of direct plans can also choose among lumpsum, SIP and STP mode of investing and between dividend, dividend reinvestment and growth options. Direct and regular plans only differ in 3 aspects – expense ratio, rate of returns and NAVs.
Also Read: Best Large Cap Funds
Lower expense ratio of direct plans
Expense ratio is the proportion of MF’s daily net assets used for meeting their annual operating expenses. Annual operating expenses involve numerous costs incurred for advertising, fund management, commissions and administration to the agents and distributors. As the fund houses do not require paying any commission to the distributors selling direct plans, the operating expenses of such plans are lower as compared to regular plans. Basis the fund category, the operating expenses of direct plans is up to 1% lower than their regular counterpart, which translates to lower expense ratio for direct plans.
A Good Credit Score ensures you manage Your Finances Well Check Score
Higher returns from direct plans
Lower expense ratios of direct plans result in higher returns. As savings in distribution expenses remain invested in direct plans, it starts to generate returns on their own owing to the compounding effect. While the difference tends to be marginal in the initial years, over the long run it becomes substantial.
Also Read: Best Mid Cap Funds
Higher Net Asset Value (NAV) of direct plans
The NAV of direct plans is higher than their regular counterpart because of their higher returns. As the operating expenses of the fund is reduced from its net AUM, the lower expense ratio of its direct plan results in higher NAVs. Moreover, the difference in NAV tends to get wider as the compounding power comes into effect.
Also Read: Best Tax Saving Funds
By what margin do direct plans outperform their regular counterpart?
The level of outperformance of direct plans over regular plans primarily depends on their period of investments i.e. longer your investment horizon, higher is the outperformance and difference in their expense ratios.
For instance, assume you invest in regular plan of an equity mutual fund via SIP Rs 25,000 for 30 years at 12% annualised returns having 2% expense ratio, the corpus will grow to Rs 5.17 crore at the end of the tenure.
If the same amount of Rs 25,000 is invested via SIP in direct plan of the same fund for the same tenure having 1% expense ratio, your corpus would grow to Rs 6.46 crore at the end of the tenure. This is a huge difference of Rs 1.29 crore with direct plan corpus outperforming its regular counterpart by about 20%.
Also Read: Best Multicap Funds
Comparison of returns from Direct Plans & Regular Plan
| Regular Plan | Direct Plan | |
| Monthly SIP Amount | Rs 25,000 | Rs 25,000 |
| Investment Tenure | 30 years | 30 years |
| Annualised Return | 12% | 12% |
| Expense Ratio | 2% | 1% |
| Final Corpus (at the end of the SIP tenure) | Rs 5.17 crore | Rs 6.46 crore |
| Outperformance by Direct plan | Rs 1.29 crore (Around 20% more than regular plan) | |
Where to purchase direct plans from?
Direct plans can be purchased by retail investors from MF houses or their respective Registrar and Transfer Agents (RTA) either online or through physical application. However, this is a cumbersome process as you will have to apply separately with each fund house or their RTAs. In case of online investing, it results in creation of multiple IDs and passwords and duplication of paperwork.
Investors can instead buy direct plans from online MF marketplaces and independent financial advisors via a single medium by paying advisory fee. While you will pay the fee directly to the concerned marketplaces or advisor, it will not get deducted from your funds’ NAV. Owing to the emergence of alternative business models, some online financial marketplaces like paisabazaar.com are also offering direct plans where investors do not need to pay any advisory fee, annual maintenance fee and various other charges.
22 Comments
How simply you describe both of the plans.anybody can understand it easily. Thank you mam for sharing this article.
Thanks Shazia for an informative article about direct vs regular mutual funds. Can you suggest how to diversity a retirement corpus of about 3 crore to ensure 2 lakhs per month income for next 20-30 years while growing the principle as well to its original value or more?
Hi Akash,
As you want your principal amount back at the end of the post-retirement tenure, a portion of your portfolio has to be invested in equities to generate higher returns. The corpus generated from your equity investments has to be redeemed in a staggered manner at periodical intervals and transferred to debt funds for generating regular income.
Hence, invest about Rs 1.75 crore in ultra-short duration bond funds and activate systematic withdrawal plan (SWP) in them. Invest the rest Rs 1.25 crore in large cap equity funds. The amount invested in ultra-short duration bond funds will be able to sustain your monthly withdrawal of Rs 2 lakh till 10 years assuming an annualised return of 7% p.a. In the meanwhile, your large cap investments will grow to Rs 3.88 crore in 10 years assuming an annualised return of 12%.
Withdraw Rs 1.75 crore from your equity corpus and invest it in ultra short duration funds and activate SWP in them for generating your monthly income. This again should be able to sustain your Rs 2 lakh monthly income for another 10 years. The remaining Rs 2 crore in your equity corpus will grow to Rs 6.20 crore in those 10 years assuming an annualised return of 12%. Repeat this cycle after the completion of 20th year of investment. This sort of investment cycle will ensure that your principal component will outlast your retirement life while generating enough returns for you.
I am currently invested Rs 10000 in HDFC Index Fund ( sensex plan) from last 3 months .Fund generated returns of around 25% in 3 months .Should i remain invested or book my profits. Plz suggest
Hi Varun,
We always advise equity mutual funds investments and redemptions based on one’s financial goals and time horizons. This applies to ETF and Index Funds as well. We never suggest market timing for making investment and redemption decisions.
It is helpful but I still have a question. Since direct growth plan still saves around 0.75% and any beginner could start in mutual funds, why people still look forward to regular plan instead of growth plan?
Hi Deepak,
Growth and dividend plans are available in both regular and direct plans. I assume that people go for regular funds because they are not confident of the fund choices they make. more traditional investors also like to physically meet with officials to be satisfied of where their money is invested.
I hope mutual fund investment direct plan on monthly dividend return is not good idea, the units allotment is less as NAV is higher, the dividend given per unit basis, thence it is proved direct plant is loss.
I any body have detail analysis on this HDFC BALANCED ADVANTAGE MONTHLY DIVIDEND PLAN, PLEASE SHARE IT.